To reproduce: - Add data items which have category, and set the SelectionMode to MultiExtended - Then use the following code and select items from different category: private void RadListControl1_SelectedItemsChanged(object sender, NotifyCollectionChangedEventArgs e) { if (e.NewItems == null) { return; } var newCategory = (((RadListDataItem) e.NewItems[0]).DataBoundItem as MyData).Category; var prevCategory = (radListControl1.SelectedItem.DataBoundItem as MyData).Category; if (newCategory != prevCategory && radListControl1.SelectedItems.Count > 1) { radListControl1.SuspendSelectionEvents = true; //exception var items = radListControl1.SelectedItems.ToList(); for (int i = 0; i < items.Count - 1; i++) { items[i].Selected = false; } //after this the selection is broken and the user cannot select an item //radListControl1.SelectedItem = null; radListControl1.SuspendSelectionEvents = false; } }